Skip to main content

A former remote fishing outpost, this island has been transformed into a unique private haven for those seeking authentic barefoot luxury

Accommodating up to 28 guests throughout four individual villas, Over Yonder Cay private island provides an unrivalled luxury experience. This paradise island, situated in the Bahamas’ Exuma Chain, boasts 72 acres of unsurpassed beauty.

Across the island, there are numerous amenities and communal areas where guests can gather to relax and socialise. These include a beach club for enjoying convivial meals, sunset drinks, or evening dance parties, a spa cabana for indulgent treatments, and a variety of sports facilities. Golf enthusiasts will be delighted by the unique nine-hole par-three golf course, tennis lovers can take advantage of the floodlit court, while volleyball players can enjoy games on the beach. Additionally, hikers have access to a wide range of pathways to explore.

Guests also receive complimentary access to the island’s boats and water equipment, including crewed motorboats for fishing, scuba diving, and snorkelling, as well as crewed sailing yachts. Additionally, jet skis, underwater sea scooters, and a variety of inflatables are available. For those interested in water sports, there’s also equipment for kitesurfing, windsurfing, paddleboarding, kayaking, wakeboarding, and water skiing.

After a day of enjoying what the island and its surrounding waters have to offer, guests can retreat to the privacy of their own luxury villa, each with its unique character and charm.

Perched atop a hill, Meridian House is the grandest of the four villas. It features a stunning wraparound infinity pool, a bubbling Jacuzzi, and a spacious covered terrace with dining and lounge areas. Inside, there is a beautiful conservatory with a grand piano, a 12-seater cinema room, and a state-of-the-art gym. The villa also offers spa facilities, including a sauna, hammam, massage suite, and beauty salon. It can accommodate up to eight guests in its four bedrooms: one master suite with a spacious en-suite bathroom, dressing room, viewing tower, and private garden, along with three guest suites, each equipped with en-suite facilities and private terraces or courtyards.

Just a few steps from Whale Bone Beach, Villa West Sands takes full advantage of its beachfront location with outdoor dining and lounging areas on a covered terrace, complete with a fire pit and a Jacuzzi. Inside, the villa features an open-plan lounge, a dining area, a kitchen, and four bedrooms that can accommodate up to eight guests. The master suite offers stunning ocean views along with a wraparound balcony. The spacious guest suite also features a balcony and a private lounge area, while the two ground-floor guest bedrooms are well-appointed and share a Hollywood-style bathroom.

Villa East Cove is situated at an elevated position, offering breathtaking views of the Exuma Sound. It features a private beach, a stunning three-tiered infinity pool, and a Jacuzzi. It also boasts extensive outdoor lounge and dining areas, perfect for relaxation and socialising. Inside, there is an open-plan lounge, dining, and kitchen area, along with a media room and four bedrooms that accommodate six to eight guests. Both the master and guest suites feature wraparound balconies, while the guest bedrooms are ideal for families, with each containing a queen bed and a single loft bed, as well as a shared Hollywood bathroom.

Finally, on the southern tip of the island, lies Villa South Point. It is flanked by shallow waters teeming with aquatic life and enjoys spectacular sunrise and sunset views. Outdoors, it features a covered terrace with a Jacuzzi and a cosy fire pit, as well as spacious lounge and dining areas. Indoors, the villa comprises an open-plan lounge, dining and kitchen area, a games room, and three bedrooms. It sleeps four to six guests across a master suite with balcony access and two guest bedrooms with a shared Hollywood bathroom.

Guests can navigate the island by gold cart, bicycle or boat. They also have access to a private deepwater marina, which can accommodate multiple yachts and offers both floating and fixed docks.

With these exclusive amenities, along with a full team of friendly staff to cater to every need, Over Yonder Cay offers a truly luxurious private island experience.

Highlights

Heated Swimming Pools

Heated Swimming Pools

Private Beach

Private Beach

Spa

Spa

Services

Included

Available extras

Enhance Your Stay with Personalised Services

After booking, your dedicated concierge will craft the perfect experience — tailored to your preferences. From everyday essentials to exclusive experiences, our curated add-ons elevate every villa stay.

Essential

Essential

Signature

Signature

Prestige

Prestige

Features

Indoor

Outdoor

Bedrooms

This property comfortably accommodates up to 28 guests in its 15 bedrooms.

MERIDIAN HOUSE – GROUND FLOOR
Master Suite 1 – double bed, dressing room, en-suite bathroom with dual vanity, Jacuzzi bathtub & separate shower, private viewing tower, terrace & garden, and direct spa access
Guest Suite 2 – double bed, en-suite bathroom with dual vanity, bathtub & separate shower, private courtyard and garden access
Guest Suite 3 – double bed, en-suite bathroom with dual vanity, bathtub & separate shower, private courtyard and garden access
Guest Suite 4 – double bed, en-suite bathroom with dual vanity, bathtub & separate shower, private courtyard and garden access

VILLA WEST SANDS – FIRST FLOOR
Master Suite 5 – double bed, lounge area, en-suite bathroom with Jacuzzi bathtub & separate shower, and private wraparound balcony
VIP Suite 6 – double bed, lounge area, en-suite bathroom with shower, and private balcony

VILLA WEST SANDS – GROUND FLOOR
Guest Bedroom 7 – double bed, shared bathroom with dual vanity & bathtub/shower, and private terrace
Guest Bedroom 8 – double bed, shared bathroom with dual vanity & bathtub/shower, and private terrace

VILLA EAST COVE – FIRST FLOOR
Master Suite 9 – king-size bed, en-suite bathroom with dual vanity, bathtub & separate shower, private wraparound balcony, and private terrace
Guest Bedroom 10 – queen size bed + single loft bed, shared bathroom with bathtub/shower, and private balcony
Guest Bedroom 11 – queen size bed + single loft bed, shared bathroom with bathtub/shower, and private balcony
VIP Suite 12 – king-size bed, en-suite bathroom with shower, and private wraparound balcony

VILLA SOUTH POINT
Master Suite 13 – king-size bed, en-suite bathroom with shower, and terrace access
Guest Bedroom 14 – double bed, shared bathroom with shower, and terrace access
Guest Bedroom 15 – double bed, shared bathroom with shower, and terrace access

View floorplan

Location

Disclaimer: the location on the map may be approximate due to privacy reasons.

About the area

Over Yonder Cay is a private island located in the Exuma Chain, in the southern part of The Bahamas. It is situated 110 kilometres from Nassau and Great Exuma, both of which are reachable in just 30 minutes by seaplane. The island can also be accessed by boat or helicopter.

The island provides various land activities such as golf, tennis, yoga, and beach volleyball. It also offers an array of water activities, including fishing, sailing, snorkelling, diving, and numerous water sports like kitesurfing, waterskiing, paddleboarding, and sea kayaking.

The Exumas offer a great selection of attractions to explore, many of which are only 15 minutes away by boat or seaplane. Notable highlights include taking a seaplane tour to a secluded sand spit for a picnic and beach party, as well as visiting the famous Norman’s Cay, home to a sunken seaplane wreck.

Distances

Frequently asked questions

Inclusions vary by property but generally cover accommodation, cleaning services, and basic utilities. Some villas may also include additional services such as concierge, breakfast, or a private chef. Full details can be found on each villa’s page. If a service is not included in the price, our concierge team can arrange it for you, ensuring a fully personalised stay. Let us know your preferences, and we’ll take care of the rest!
Booking is simple! If you have a specific villa in mind, click "Send Enquiry" on its page. If you're considering multiple options, click the heart icon to save your favorites and send one enquiry for all of them. Our team will check availability and send you a detailed offer within 24 hours. Need help choosing? We’re happy to assist!
Yes, a deposit is required at the time of booking, typically 30% of the total amount. The remaining balance is usually due 30 to 90 days before check-in, depending on the property. Some villas may have different payment schedules, which will be specified in the offer we send you.
We accept bank transfers and major credit cards. Payment details will be provided during the booking process.
Yes, we offer a wide range of services, including in-villa options like private chefs, chauffeurs, and spa treatments, as well as activities such as yacht charters, wine tastings, and guided tours. We can also arrange experiences for the rest of your holiday, even beyond your villa stay. After booking, your dedicated concierge will contact you to customise your itinerary.
Yes, most high-end villas require a minimum stay of 7 nights, usually starting from a Saturday. However, many properties offer flexibility during certain times of the year, except for peak seasons like summer and Christmas holidays, which typically have stricter requirements. A smaller number of properties accept shorter stays year-round. If you have specific dates in mind, please contact us for availability.
Yes, we offer commission to travel agents booking on behalf of their clients. The commission amount varies by property, please contact us for specific details regarding a particular villa.

Have more questions?

Connect with our Villa Experts – we’ll handle the rest.

-

Prices available on request. From USD 357,000 per week

Superb Service

5/5

"Thank you My Private Villas for the outstanding service. Paolo Macchiaroli goes above and beyond to accommodate all our needs, making for an exquisite vacation."

— Sir Anthony Hopkins

Why guests love our villas...

Wonderful vacation in an island paradise

5/5

"Excellent and very responsive service. They coordinated all aspects of our stay very efficiently. A great team to work with."

— Lynette

Top villa rental company

5/5

"Best villa rental company we have ever used. We found them to be easy to communicate with, expert, friendly and cooperative, to assure that our stay was enjoyable."

— Jim Long

Amazing

5/5

"Service was very excellent. Owners were very helpful and caring."

— Trusted Client

Servizio impeccabile, ci hanno organizzato la vacanza in ogni dettaglio.

5/5

"Cura del cliente ai massimi livelli. Assistenza h24, profonda conoscenza della proprietá e della destinazione. Hanno reso la vacanza indimenticabile. Saro’ sicuramente loro cliente a vita, assolutamente migliori di qualsiasi altro operatore di cui ho usufruito."

— Francesco

Wonderful to work with!

5/5

"Best company to schedule a vacation with! My family and friends were celebrating my 50th birthday in the south of France. My Private Villas helped me with the villa selection (it was stunning!), the chef and dinner party at the house. It was all fabulous! Couldn't have asked for a better celebration. We will definitely be using them again...possibly when our daughter graduates college in a few years!"

— Cristina March

First class operation!

5/5

"The attention to detail and ease of booking process was excellent. The customer support was 1st class. The on-site team at the villa was superb, and arranged anything we needed."

— Trusted Client

Best holiday ever!

5/5

"The house was outstanding and exactly as described. Furthermore Francesca provided a very friendly, proactive and highly efficient follow-up on all the details we requested to make this our best family holiday ever."

— Simon Coombe

Wonderful villa in spectacular surroundings!

5/5

"A very thorough approach to the process of advising on numerous points of detail raised by a 10 strong party whose ages ranged from 7 ti 69. Clear understanding of the facilities and services on offer and how they could be tailored to accommodate us all. Communications were clear and questions addressed promptly. Issue on arrival was dealt with promptly and to our satisfaction."

— Dennis

10/10 Company!

5/5

"Great service! They helped us throughout the whole process, even though it was very last minute. Francesca is wonderful, looking forward to working with her again: she made the whole experience 10 times better."

— Trusted Client

Explore similar properties